In the 1960’s, students … literally put their lives on the line in the hopes of spurring a more humane society.


Web 2.0 indignation: Digger online threats displace Facebooker turnkey riots

Posted by Donna Bogatin @ 7:44 am

Digg This!

The Michael Arrington (see “Digg vs. Diggers?”) fueled indignation effused this weekend by “top” Diggers recalls the recent outraged Facebooker “riots.”


What do the current minority of disgruntled Diggers have in common with the past minority of restive Facebookers?


All are non-paying users of free Web based services “threatening” the owners of the sites which they use at no-cost.


What is the nature of the threats? Operate your sites the way we want you to, or else.


Or else what?


We, non-paying users, will take our “community” elsewhere. Really? Where to?


To another free-to-use Web service, one that will show us the appreciation we deserve by operating the site the way we say it should be operated.


Contrary to popular perception, Facebook owners were not cowed by turnkey, online petitions emanating from a minority of Facebookers. Digg owners also do not appear to be cowed by blogosphere, online letters emanating from a minority of Diggers. 


Is passionate indignation always a good thing? In “Facebook ‘activism’: how about a greater good?” I note:

In the old (very old) days, student activism meant something, stood for something and required some effort and personal risk taking. In the 1960’s, students took to the streets and literally put their lives on the line in the hopes of spurring a more humane society.

In today’s Facebook and MySpace worlds, however, student “activism” is self-centered and effortless. In “Homework for Facebook students: hack your own social network” I cite a Facebook “activist” on why he believes changes to Facebook services provisioning harm “Civil & Human Rights”:

"We all know who has dumped who, who is doing what, and who doesn’t like something anymore. This is invasive, and while it is displayed for others to see, it is not meant to bombard their homepage."

In the 1960’s, students marched in the face of police armed force to stop the bombing of people; in 2006, students click a computer mouse to stop text “bombardments” of personal vanity homepages.

What is the mighty Facebook “uprising”? It is an online gossip fest about the right to gossip online, for free.

I conclude:

if “user production, users in charge, taking back the Net” nets an even more self-centered populace, is “users in charge” a good thing?

ALSO SEE: "Web 2.0 ‘users in control’: Of who, and to what means"
"Facebook to students: Zuckerberg and VCs are in ‘control’"
"Web 2.0 hype: Popularity without profits"

Comments | Blog This | E-mail This | Print This | Permalink

Categories: Web 2.0, Culture, User-Generated Content, Social Web, Digg, Amateur Content, Self-Promotion, Facebook, Social Networking, Social Media

Previous Post





Bien, anoche no hemos puesto, por supuesto, nuestras vidas en riesgo, pero lo que sí en definitiva hemos hecho es salir de el confinamiento cibernético, de la queja perenne, y además tenemos la esperanza de una sociedad más humana, igualitaria, liberal, etc., etc., etc.


Palabras es sólo el primer paso, pero la acción es una consecuencia inevitable de esta inquietud por mundo mejor. El carpintero -sorry, no more "real names" from now on, sometimes they DO NOT necessarily share my perceptions, but it’s OK, we can reach an agreement, what about you? – me ha dicho que subestimamos a los adolescentes, que pensamos que hay que darles como papilla todo digerido y arrearlos, siendo que ellos tienen una idea muy clara de lo que está mal y lo que quieren. Si esto es cierto, quisiera al igual que con los conservadores que andan POR AHI, escucharlos, discutir, debatir con ellos que me retroalimentaran y enriquecieran mis y nuestras luchas, trincheras como le recuerdo cada vez que puedo a la semita, porque afortunadamente NO ESTAMOS SOLOS. 


!!!Salgamos pues de nuestras ivory towers!!! !!!Derribemos nuestros bunkers intelectuales, así sean cibernéticos!!! !!!Tomemos las calles PACIFICAMENTE!!! !!!Apoyemos nobles causas!!! !!!No están solos recuérdenlo, siempre tendrán mi hombro y el de otros como ustedes!!!


P.D. Perfect timing!!! Espero hoy les tenga algo sobre pacifismo, ya que por lo menos dos hechos me lo solicitan:


1. Los "bombazos" en el DF.

2. Un correo de retroalimentación en el que me tachan de ingenuo. Neta que a veces sí lo soy, ustedes lo saben mejor que YO.



Norwich, 8/11/06





This entry was posted in News and politics. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s